Late Pleistocene horse Equus (Equus) ferus (Perissodactyla, Equidae) from the Cis-Baikal and Transbaikalia

N.A. Plasteeva and A.M. Klement’ev

Proceedings of the Zoological Institute RAS, 2017, 321(2): 180–198 · https://doi.org/10.31610/trudyzin/2017.321.2.180

Full text

Abstract

The paper presents morphological examination of caballoid horse remains (Equus (Equus)) from the Baikal region. The study area stretches from Angara river basin up to western Transbaikalia. Fossil material was dated to the second half of the Late Pleistocene, from Kargin Interstadial to the Late Glacial. In all 18 upper and lower jaws, 34 isolated teeth, 37 metacarpal and 56 metatarsal bones were measured. Comparative analysis of horse remains from the Cis-Baikal area, Transbaikalia, and contemporaneous material from the south of Eastern Europe, the Ural Mountains, Western and North-Eastern Siberia revealed marked intraspecific variation in the Late Pleistocene horses. Observed size variation in skeletal elements reflects temporal and regional variation in horse body size. Multivariate analysis showed that despite the significant size variation between local populations, fossil horses were homogeneous in their morphology. Relative proportions of metacarpal and metatarsal bones remained constant through the Late Pleistocene. Horse remains from the Cis-Baikal area and Transbaikalia were attributed to Equus ferus – a circumpolar species in the Late Pleistocene. Przewalski’s horse (Equus przewalskii) differs from fossil horses by the relative proportions of the limb bones. Based on morphometric analysis we can conclude that E. przewalskii did not inhabit the Baikal region during the Late Pleistocene.

Key words

Cis-Baikal, Equus, horses, Late Pleistocene, taxonomy, Transbaikalia

Submitted September 27, 2016 · Accepted March 14, 2017 · Published June 26, 2017

References

Arembovsky I.V. 1958. Stratigraphy of the Quaternary sediments on the south of Eastern Siberia. Trudy Irkutskogo universiteta im. Zhdanova, 14: 9–55. [In Russian].

Bennett D. and Hoffmann R.S. 1999. Equus caballus. Mammalian Species, 628: 1–14. https://doi.org/10.2307/3504442

Bessudnov A.N., Bessudnov A.A, Burova N.D., Lavrushin Yu.A. and Spiridonova E.A. 2012. Certain results on investigation of Paleolithic sites near Divnogorye khutor, Middle Don region (2007–2011 yrs). Short communications of the Institute of archaeology, 227: 146–156 [In Russian].

Derevianko A.P., Shunkov M.V., Agadjanian A.K., Baryshnikov G.F., Malaeva E.M., Ulianov V.A., Kulik N.A., Postnov A.V. and Anoikin A.A. 2003. Paleoenvironment and Paleolithic human occupation of Gorny Altai. Subsistence and adaptation in the vicinity of Denisova cave. Institute of archaeology and ethnography, Novosibirsk, 448 p. [In Russian].

Eisenmann V. 1980. Les Chevaux (Equus sensu lato) fossiles et actuels: Crânes et dents jugales supérieures. Éditions du Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, Paris, 186 p.

Eisenmann V. Equus actuels et récemment éteints / Vera Eisenmann: [online resource]. URL: http://www.vera-eisenmann.com/equidae-equus-actuels-et-recemment-eteints-rubrique17.html

Eisenmann V., Alberdi M.T., de Giuli G. and Staesche U. 1988. Studying fossil horses. Vol. 1: Methodology. Collected papers after the New York International Hipparion Conference (1981, New York). E.J. Brill, Leiden-New York-København-Köln: 1–71.

Ermolova N.M. 1978. Theriofauna of the Angara River valley in the Late Anthropogene. Nauka, Novosibirsk, 222 p. [In Russian].

Foronova I.V. 1990. Fossil horses of the Kuznetsk Basin. Institute of geology and geophysics, Novosibirsk, 131 p. [In Russian].

Gentry A., Clutton-Brock J. and Groves C.P. 1996. Proposed conservation of usage of 15 mammal specific names based on wild species which are antedated by or contemporary with those based on domestic animals. Bulletin of Zoological Nomenclature, 53: 28–33. https://doi.org/10.5962/bhl.part.14102

Germonpre M. and Lbova L. 1996. Mammalian Remains from the Upper Palaeolithic Site of Kamenka, Buryatia (Siberia). Journal of Archaeological Science, 23: 35–57. https://doi.org/10.1006/jasc.1996.0004

Gromov V.I. 1937. Faunal and geological data on Paleolithic site Malta near Irkutsk. Materials of the Soviet section of the International association of the study of the Quaternary (INQUA), Vol. 1. Leningrad: 269–301. [In Russian].

Gromova V.I. 1949. History of horses (genus Equus) in the Old World. Paleontological institute, Moscow, 374 p. [In Russian].

Gromova V.I. 1959. On the skeleton of the tarpan (Equus caballus Gmelini Ant.) and other present day wild horses (part I). Bulletin of Moscow Society of Naturalists. Biological series, 64: 99–124. [In Russian].

Heptner V.G., Nasimovich A.A. and Bannikov A.G. 1961. Genus Equus. In: V.G. Heptner and N.P. Naumov (Eds). Mammals of the Soviet Union. Vol. 1. Vysshaya shkola, Moscow: 696–729. [In Russian].

International Comission on Zoological Nomenclature. Opinion 2027 (Case 3010). 2003. Usage of 17 specific names based on wild species which are pre-dated by or contemporary with those based on domestic animals (Lepidoptera, Osteichthyes, Mammalia): conserved. Bulletin of Zoological Nomenclature, 60: 81–84.

Kalmykov N.P. 1990. Pleistocene large mammal fauna of Cis-Baikal and Western Transbaikalia. Buryat Scientific Centre, Ulan-Ude, 115 p. [In Russian].

Kalmykov N.P. 1999. Theriofauna of the Udinsk forest-steppe (Khotyk 3 site). In: L.V. Lbova (Ed.). Human Paleoecology in the Baikal Asia: Field Excursion Guide. Buryat Scientific Centre, Ulan-Ude: 41–43. [In Russian].

Kalmykov N.P. and Shabunova V.V. 2006. Steppe mammals of western Transbaikalia in the Paleolithic). Materials of the IV International symposium: Steppes of the Northern Eurasia (4–8 September 2006, Orenburg). Orenburg: 331–333. [In Russian].

Kasparov A.K. 1986. Mammal remains from the Late Paleolithic settlement Sukhotino-4 in Transbaikalia. Trudy Zoologicheskogo Instituta, 149: 98–106. [In Russian].

Kirikov S.V. 1966. Game animals, natural environment and the human. Nauka, Moskow, 346 p. [In Russian].

Klement’ev A.M. 2011. Holocene fauna of Selenga midlands (remains from archaeological sites). Materials of the Russian Conference: Youth and science (17–20 May 2011, Chita). Chita: 47–49. [In Russian].

Klement’ev A.M. 2013. Fauna of the Late Karga Period of the Irkutsk Amphitheater. Proceedings of the Irkutsk State University. Series Geoarchaeology. Ethnology. Antropology, 1(2): 30–43. [In Russian].

Klement’ev A.M. 2014. Early Holocene fauna of the Northern Angara (materials of archaeological sites). Proceedings of the Irkutsk State University. Series Geoarchaeology. Ethnology. Antropology, 8: 31–44. [In Russian].

Klement’ev A.M. and Novoseltseva V.M. 2013. Fauna of geoarchaeological object Ust-Keul I (Northern Angara region). Proceedings of the Irkutsk State University. Series Geoarchaeology. Ethnology. Antropology, 2(3): 3–14. [In Russian].

Kosintsev P.A., Plasteeva N.A. and Vasiliev S.K. 2013. Wild horses (Equus (Equus) s. l.) of Western Siberia in the Holocene. Russian Journal of Zoology, 92(9): 1107–1116. [In Russian]. https://doi.org/10.7868/S0044513413090092

Kuzmin Ya.V., Orlova L.A., Zenin V.N., Lbova L.V. and Dement’ev V.N. 2011. Radiocarbon dating of the Paleolithic of Siberia and Russian Far East: materials for ¹⁴C data catalogue (at the end of 2010 yr.). Stratum plus, 1: 1–30. [In Russian].

Kuzmin Y.V., van der Plicht J. and Sulerzhitsky L.D. 2014. Puzzling radiocarbon dates for the Upper Paleolithic site of Sungir (central Russian Plain). Radiocarbon, 56: 451–459. https://doi.org/10.2458/56.17038

Kuzmina I.E. 1985. Horse from the Late Pleistocene of the Urals. Trudy Zoologicheskogo Instituta, 131: 64–88. [In Russian].

Kuzmina I.E. 1990. Late Pleistocene horse of the Ussuri krai. Trudy Zoologicheskogo Instituta, 212: 49–58. [In Russian].

Lau A.N., Peng L., Goto H., Chemnick L., Ryder O. and Makova K.D. 2009. Horse domestication and conservation genetics of Przewalski’s horse inferred from sex chromosomal and autosomal sequences. Molecular Biology and Evolution, 26: 199–208. https://doi.org/10.1093/molbev/msn239

Lazarev P.A. 1980. Anthropogene horses of Yakutia. Nauka, Moskow, 190 p. [In Russian].

Lipnina E.A. and Kogai S.A. 2015. Lithic industry of Upper Paleolithic Site Gerasimova I. Proceedings of the Irkutsk State University. Series Geoarchaeology. Ethnology. Antropology, 14: 3–23. [In Russian].

Malikov D.G. 2015. Large mammals of the Minusinsk depression in Middle-Late Pleistocene, stratigraphic value and paleozoogeography. Abstract of the Candidate of Biological Sciences thesis. Tomsk State University, Tomsk, 22 p. [In Russian].

Nanova O.G. 2008. Analysis of variation of the cheek in three canid species (Mammalia: Canidae) by means of standard and geometric morphometrics. In: I.Ya. Pavlinov and M.V. Kalyakin (Eds). Zoological research. Archives of the zoological museum of Moscow State University. Vol. 49. Moscow University publishing, Moscow: 413–427. [In Russian].

Nomokonova T.Yu., Losey R.J. and Goryunova O.I. 2009. Fauna of multilayered settlement Berloga (Small sea strait, Baikal). Problems of archaeology, ethnography and anthropology of Siberia and adjacent territories, 15: 177–181. [In Russian].

Orlando L., Ginolhac A., Zhang G., Froese D., Froese D., Albrechtsen A., Stiller M., Schubert M., Cappellini E., Petersen B., Moltke I., Johnson PL., Fumagalli M., Vilstrup J.T., Raghavan M., Korneliussen T., Malaspinas A.S., Vogt J., Szklarczyk D., Kelstrup C.D., Vinther J., Dolocan A., Stenderup J., Velazquez A.M., Cahill J., Rasmussen M., Wang X., Min J., Zazula G.D., Seguin-Orlando A., Mortensen C., Magnussen K., Thompson J.F., Weinstock J., Gregersen K., Røed K.H., Eisenmann V., Rubin C.J., Miller D.C., Antczak D.F., Bertelsen M.F., Brunak S., Al-Rasheid K.A., Ryder O., Andersson L., Mundy J., Krogh A., Gilbert M.T., Kjær K., Sicheritz-Ponten T., Jensen L.J., Olsen J.V., Hofreiter M., Nielsen R., Shapiro B., Wang J. and Willerslev E. 2013. Recalibrating Equus evolution using the genome sequence of an early Middle Pleistocene horse. Nature, 499: 74–78. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature12323

Orlando L., Metcalf J.L, Alberdi M.T., Telles-Antunes M., Bonjean D., Otte M., Martin F., Eisenmann V., Mashkour M., Morello F., Prado J.L., Salas-Gismondi R., Shockey B.J., Wrinn P.J., Vasil’ev S.K., Ovodov N.D., Cherry M.I., Hopwood B., Male D., Austin J.J., Hänni C. and Cooper A. 2009. Revising the recent evolutionary history of equids using ancient DNA. Proceedings of National Academy of Sciences, 106(51): 21754–21759. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.0903672106

Ovodov N.D. 1987. Fauna of Paleolithic settlements Tolbaga and Varvarina Gora in western Transbaikalia. Materials of Russian Conference: The environment and ancient human in Late Anthropogene (2–8 June 1986, Ulan-Ude). Buryat Scientific Centre, Ulan-Ude: 122–140. [In Russian].

Ovodov N.D. and Panychev V.A. 1982. Fauna and radiocarbon dating of the Neolithic settlement Sagan-Zaba in Baikal region. Materials of Regional Conference: Problems of archaeology and ethnography in Siberia (7–9 April 1982, Irkutsk). Irkutsk State University publishing, Irkutsk: 66–68. [In Russian].

Plasteeva N.D., Burova N.D. and Kosintsev P.A. 2012. Eastern European horses (Equus ferus Boddaert, 1785) in the end of the Late Pleistocene. Bulletin of Moscow Society of Naturalists. Biological series, 117: 3–11. [In Russian].

Plasteeva N.A. 2013. Horses (Equus (Equus)) in Late Pleistocene of Eastern Europe and the Urals. Abstract of the Candidate of Biological Sciences thesis. IPAE, Ekaterinburg, 21 p. [In Russian].

Plasteeva N.A., Vasiliev S.K. and Kosintsev P.A. 2015. Equus (Sussemionus) ovodovi Eisenmann et Vasiliev, 2011 from the Late Pleistocene of Western Siberia. Russian Journal of Theriology, 14(2): 187–200. [In Russian]. https://doi.org/10.15298/rusjtheriol.14.2.07

Plasteeva N.A. 2016. Taxonomy and distribution of the Late Pleistocene horses (genus Equus) in Western Siberia. Materials of the Russian Conference: Ecology: facts, models hypothesis (11–15 April 2016, Ekaterinburg). Institute of plant and animal ecology, Ekaterinburg: 76–83. [In Russian].

Rusanov B.S. 1968. Biostratigraphy of Cenozoic deposits of southern Yakutia. Nauka, Moscow, 459 p. [In Russian].

Shchetnikov A.A., Klement’ev A.M., Filinov I.A. and Semeney E.Yu. 2015. Large mammals from the Upper Pleistocene reference sections in the Tunka Rift Valley, south-western Baikal region. Stratigraphy and geological correlation, 23(2): 104–128. [In Russian]. https://doi.org/10.1134/S0869593815020057

Shchetnikov A.A., Klement’ev A.M., Semeney E.Yu., Sizov A.V., Filinov I.A. and Nikitenok V.V. 2012. Fossil mammal fauna from the Ust-Oda site (Upper Pleistocene, Pre-Baikal region). Baikal zoological journal, 2: 5–11. [In Russian].

Sinitsyn A.A., Praslov N.D., Svezhencev Yu.S. and Sulerzhitsky L.D. 1997. Radiocarbon chronology of the Upper Paleolithic of the Eastern Europe. In: A.A. Sinitsyn, N.D. Praslov (eds). Radiocarbon chronology of the Upper Paleolithic of the Eastern Europe and Northern Asia. Problems and perspectives. Saint Petersburg: 21–66. [In Russian].

Spasskaya N.N. 2001. Intraspecific morphological variation in Przewalski’s horse Equus przewalskii Poljakov, 1881. Abstract of the Candidate of Biological Sciences thesis. A.N. Severtsov IEE, Moscow, 25 p. [In Russian].

Tarasov P.E., Bezrukova E.V. and Krivonogov S.K. 2009. Late Glacial and Holocene changes in vegetation cover and climate in southern Siberia derived from a 15 kyr long pollen record from Lake Kotokel. Climate of the Past, 5: 285–295. https://doi.org/10.5194/cp-5-285-2009

Tarasov P., Bezrukova E., Karabanov E., Nakagawa T., Wagner M., Kulagina N., Letunova P., Abzaeva A., Granoszewski W. and Riedel, F. 2007. Vegetation and climate dynamics during the Holocene and Eemian interglacials derived from Lake Baikal pollen records. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, 252(3–4): 440–457. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.palaeo.2007.05.002

van Asperen E.N. 2010. Ecomorphological adaptations to climate and substrate in late Middle Pleistocene caballoid horses. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, 297: 584–596. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.palaeo.2010.09.007

van Asperen E.N. 2013. Implications of age variation and sexual dimorphism in modern Equids for middle Pleistocene Equid taxonomy. International Journal of Osteoarchaeology, 23: 1–12. https://doi.org/10.1002/oa.1231

van Asperen E.N. and Stefaniak K. 2011. Biśnik Cave and its biostratigraphical position based on equid remains. Acta zoologica cracoviensia, 54: 55–76. https://doi.org/10.3409/azc.54a_1-2.55-76

van Asperen E.N., Stefaniak K., Proskurnyak I. and Ridush B. 2012. Equids from Emine-Bair-Khosar Cave (Crimea, Ukraine): cooccurrence of the stenonid Equus hydruntinus and the caballoid E. ferus latipes based on skull and postcranial remains. Palaeontologia Electronica, 15(1), 5A, 28p. https://doi.org/10.26879/280

Vasiliev S.K., Zenin A.N., Serdyuk N.V. and Ul’yanov V.A. 2008. New data on Hyena cave (northwestern Altai). Problems of archaeology, ethnography and anthropology of Siberia and adjacent territories, 14: 21–31. [In Russian].

Weinstock J., Willerslev E., Sher A., Tong W., Ho S.Y., Rubenstein D., Storer J., Burns J., Martin L., Bravi C., Prieto A., Froese D., Scott E., Xulong L. and Cooper A. 2005. Evolution, Systematics, and Phylogeography of Pleistocene Horses in the New World: A Molecular Perspective. PLoS Biology, 3: 1373. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.0030241